Quarterly Commentary - March 2008
By Patrick Ifrah
During the first quarter of 2008, the financial markets struggled with the on
going credit crisis of which we haven't seen the likes since the savings and
loan fiasco of the early 1980s and1990s. In response to this crisis, the
concerns over the rest of the economy and the uncertainty that prevailed, the
Federal Reserve lowered the fed funds rate from 4.25% to 2.25% as well as the
discount rate from 4.75% to 2.5% during the first quarter of 2008. Furthermore,
the Federal Reserve opened the discount window to investment banks and reduced
the capital holding requirements for Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.
These are certainly unusual times and policymakers are pursuing aggressive and
creative strategies to reduce the cost of capital, inject considerable liquidity
and attempt to facilitate activities in the credit markets. The Federal Reserve
also allowed its primary dealers, the major financial firms through which the
central bank conducts its business, to borrow from it using mortgage-backed
securities as collateral. In another unusual move, the Federal Reserve decided
to lend $30 billion to JP Morgan Chase & Co. to help consummate a purchase of
Bear Stearns on the verge of imploding under the strain of its own leverage.
This type of move had not been seen since 1936 as the Federal Reserve extended
its resources beyond simply allowing the banks to borrow from its discount
window. More recently, investors had the opportunity to review a government plan
to overhaul the way Wall Street is regulated and the oversight structure
concerning the banking system. Lawmakers have voted in a stimulus package in the
form of tax rebates that should hopefully find its way back into our economy.
Much is happening in order to calm and restore our economy and the effect of
these actions will not be fully seen for probably 12 to18 months.
Investors went into the first quarter of 2008 with higher expectations thinking
that the worst might be over given the large write downs already taken by the
financial companies in the last quarter of 2007 and the anticipation of rate
cuts by the Federal Reserve. However much of the uneasiness remained with
concerns about recession, inflation, higher oil prices, a weak dollar, the
health of consumer spending and the significant unknowns related to the
widespread impact of the mortgage-backed securities which continued to fuel much
of the uncertainty. The problem today remains a highly leveraged credit system
with potentially massive and unquantifiable credit losses. The impact of
significant declines in home prices is a significant issue in that the typical
homeowner is highly leveraged and a lot of their net worth is tied to the equity
in their home. A drop in value for many can cause millions of homeowners to be
upside down on their mortgages.
The economic data continues to be weak and fear as well as risk aversion have
the potential to feed into a self fulfilling prophecy, and although certain
areas such as housing and financial sectors have experienced recessionary times,
we think that the jury is still out on whether a widespread recession is in
effect or will play out as defined by two quarters of negative growth. The
issues with the credit markets have the potential to hurt the economy, however
if the actions taken by the government work favorably and given the resiliency
of our economy we remain cautiously optimistic.
It is important to not confuse the behavior of the equity markets with that of
the economy. For the most part, the stock market is forward looking in nature
and by the time we have figured out if a recession was underway, we probably
will be in the midst of a recovery and the equity markets will most likely have
bounced back significantly from their lows looking to price in what may happen
on a forward looking basis. We feel that the equity markets are in the process
of bottoming out and given the policy shifts, the lower interest rates and the
impending stimulus, we could be on the verge of something significant on the
upside for the stock market at these valuation levels. It seems that in an
election year, there is nothing that the Fed or lawmakers aren't prepared to do
to help fix some of the problems we face. The question is will it work and will
there be any undesired side effects. It probably won't be without its usual
volatility and more negative news will continue to test the markets. We have
been at this long enough to know that patience and fortitude are always rewarded
and opportunities often present themselves when the average investor out there
continues on their tendencies to overreact to bad news. Thank you for the
opportunity to guide you during these volatile times.